Calibrate Your Business

AI consultant vs agency vs freelancer vs doing it yourself

  • Free
  • Under an hour
  • No pitch

By Karim Nassar.

How I work, compared

This is my read of how each option is usually set up, not a survey of the market. There are no vendor prices to quote here, so there is nothing to date. Agencies and freelancers vary, so the cells for them tell you what to ask.

Four ways to get AI working in your business
RowWorking with meAn agencyA freelancerDoing it yourself
Who does the workMe, in every session. One person from the first call to the handoff.A team. Ask who you will talk to and who does the work, because they can be different people.One person, often strong in one skill such as building or design.You, or someone on your team in the hours they can spare.
Where it startsYour week. I time the tasks and rank what AI should take first.Usually a scoped project. Ask what is scoped and who chose it.Usually the brief you write. A good one asks you questions first.Usually a tool you have heard about.
How they chargeBuilds are fixed price, quoted from the plan. The first call is free.Ask: fixed price, hourly or an ongoing monthly fee, and what each includes.Ask: fixed price or hourly, and what happens if the job runs over.Subscriptions, plus your own time, which is the cost people forget.
What you leave withA written, ranked plan, then a build your team can run without me, and a handoff.Whatever the contract lists. Ask who owns the work and the accounts.Whatever the brief lists. Ask for documentation of how it works.Whatever you finish. It is yours, and it may stop when you get busy.
If it does not workPaid work hits a target we agree in writing, or you get 100% of your money back.Ask for the target and the remedy in writing before you sign.Ask for the target and the remedy in writing before you start.You lose the hours, not a fee.
You want to try a chatbot for emails this weekWhere I say noNot me. A free plan and an afternoon will tell you more than a call with me.Not an agency either. It is more help than the job needs.Not needed.Yes. Start here, on one real task.
You want someone in-house every dayWhere I say noNot me. I work in sessions and hand over, I do not sit on your team.Some will embed a person. Ask.Some will work part-time on your site. Ask.Or hire an employee. That is a different decision from all four.
A large rollout across many locations or a regulated IT setupWhere I say noNot me. I work with small businesses, and a rollout that size needs a team and your IT lead.Closer to the right fit. Check their experience with your kind of rules.Rarely, on their own.No.
You are outside the Austin areaWhere I say noI focus on small businesses in and around Austin. Ask me, and I will say if I can help.Depends on the agency.Depends on the freelancer.Location does not matter.

The shaded rows are cases where I tell you not to hire me, and often not to hire anyone.

Who should pick which

  • Do it yourself if

    You have a few hours, one task in mind and the patience to try. Use a free plan first. If it works, you saved the cost of any of the other three.

  • Hire a freelancer if

    You know exactly what you want built, such as one automation or one site change, and you can write it down clearly.

  • Hire an agency if

    The job is big, spans several skills or locations, or you need a firm that will still be there to run it next year.

  • Hire me if

    You have tried AI, it is not saving you hours yet, and you do not know which task to hand over first. I start from your week, and the plan is yours to keep either way.

Questions to ask any of the four

Use these on me too. A good answer is specific, and a vague one tells you something.

  1. Who will do the work, by name? Will I talk to that person?
  2. What do I own at the end: the files, the accounts and the know-how?
  3. Is it a fixed price, hourly or an ongoing monthly fee, and what is in it?
  4. What target will we agree in writing, and what happens if it is missed?
  5. Where does my customer and business data go, and who can see it?
  6. What happens after the handoff? Can my team run it without you?

Questions people ask

Do I need a consultant if I can use ChatGPT myself?

Often not at first. If you have one task and time to try, do it yourself. A consultant helps when you have tried and the hours are not coming back, or you do not know which task to start with.

What is the difference between an AI consultant and an agency?

Size and structure. An agency is a team with roles, usually sold as a project. A consultant, in my case one person, works with you directly. The right choice depends on how big the job is, not on which label sounds better.

Is a freelancer cheaper than a consultant?

I cannot say for a freelancer I have not met. Compare the same scope in writing: what is built, who owns it, what happens if it does not work. Price alone hides all three.

Why is there no price for your help on this page?

My builds are fixed price, quoted from a written plan, so there is no honest number to show before I know your week. The call is free and you will not be pitched.

Find the first job to hand to AI

In a free call we go through your week together. You leave knowing which job to hand to AI first.

  • Free
  • 45 minutes
  • No pitch

How I wrote this page

This page has no vendor prices, so there are no dates to check. The cells for agencies and freelancers describe what to ask, not what every one of them does, because I have not surveyed the market and will not pretend to. The cells about me are what I offer today.

Book a Discovery call